Showing posts with label florida. Show all posts
Showing posts with label florida. Show all posts

Sunday, June 9, 2024

A "feral swine bomb" on the way?

 ‘We’re not gonna barbecue our way out of this’

Wild pigs, conquering all Florida counties, are now taking over the US

Wild pigs and hogs have been spotted in at least 35 states as their numbers continue to grow at a rapid pace. 

By Shira Moolten South Florida Sun Sentinel

David Prendergast loved gardening at his home in the small Miramar development that borders the Everglades. Then he woke up one morning in early May to discover his grass destroyed and his plants devoured.

A family of wild hogs had visited his home, as they had those of other residents over the last several days, leaving lawns in various states of disarray and creating a sense of panic throughout the neighborhood, though Prendergast empathized with the animals.

“I guess they’re hungry,” he told the South Florida Sun Sentinel on Friday, a couple weeks after the scare had subsided. “And they’re displaced based on the development that’s going on in our area.”

Wild hogs, an invasive species first brought to Florida by Spanish settlers in the 1500s, have now appeared in at least 35 states as their numbers continue to grow at a rapid pace, leading officials to warn of a devastating population explosion called the “feral swine bomb.”

The biggest threat the pigs pose is to agriculture, rolling around in the dirt to cool off, rooting for food and eating crops, their favorite of which is corn. Still other dangers loom on the horizon: Across the ocean, wild pigs carry a deadly disease that could decimate the U.S. pork industry. Meanwhile, growing numbers of pigs combined with increasing development over once-wild lands means greater potential for ruined gardens and rare, but possible, attacks on humans.

“Unfortunately the only solution we have right now is lethal removal,” said Dr. John Mayer, a research scientist and manager at the Savannah River National Laboratory in South Carolina who has been studying wild pigs for over 40 years. “A lot of people don’t believe there’s such thing as a pig-proof fence.”

States like Florida and Texas have long borne the brunt of the feral hog problem and have struggled to manage it as the situation has grown more dire nationally. Officials have incentivized hunters by instituting few restrictions, and people have followed, by helicopter, drone, machine gun, and various combinations of the three, all year long. Yet some, including hunters themselves, question whether the approach is overkill, especially in areas where the animals are a vital food source.

“Agencies have created this scenario where they want to eliminate the wild hog,” said Bishop Wright Jr., a longtime hunter based in West Palm Beach. “It’s not managed to keep the hog, it’s managed to eliminate the wild hog and eradicate it.”

‘Praying to God’

Craig Greene rarely feared for his life when he trapped wild pigs, at least until a day in 2008 when he was sure he was going to get eaten alive.

The longtime animal trapper was baiting a trap in a cow field in the middle of rural DeSoto County. But when he opened his sour corn, the pigs ran out of the woods, taking him off guard. He had no choice but to crawl into his own trap, which was about 3 feet tall. Greene is 6-foot-2.

The cowboys had already moved through that day and Greene had told everyone else not to go out there. No one was coming to save him.

“I’m on my hands and knees, praying to God,” he told the South Florida Sun Sentinel. “I didn’t have a pocket knife or nothing to protect myself.”

Eventually, after what felt like several hours, the hogs wandered off and Greene made it home alive, though as he walked, he couldn’t be too sure they weren’t just waiting in the trees for the right moment to pounce.

“I know when they kill you, they’ll eat you while you’re screaming,” he said. “I’d rather get eaten by an alligator.”

Though rare, wild pig attacks outnumber all species of shark attack combined. Still, the potential for dangerous interactions goes up as the pig population grows and humans develop lands where the hogs once roamed free.

“They’ve been here for 200 years and now everywhere they go they’re getting pushed out,” Greene said. “They’re doing so much major construction. So now pigs are showing up in people’s yards because the gated development is butted right up against a preserve.”

Hogs love acorns, so anyone who builds a house around an oak tree can expect a visit, he added. They often aren’t scared of people.

“I’ve had phone calls like, ‘Oh my God, I’m in my car right now, this pig is slamming his head up against my truck,‘” Greene said. “‘Come help me.’ ”

One time, the police called him because a pig was on the loose in a hotel parking lot, banging itself into cars.

Recent hog sightings have worried residents across Florida, where the pigs now exist in all 67 counties. Sarasota County, where Greene lives, has some of the biggest problems, he said, along with Charlotte and DeSoto counties. The pigs prefer the inland areas in the middle of the state, from Clewiston to the sugar cane fields in Belle Glade.

“There are a number of factors that contribute to wild hog reports from the public,” an FWC spokesperson said in a text. “Seasonal food availability/mast production, year-round reproduction, and increased human population in Florida resulting in more people living in areas near ranging wild hogs are large contributors to wild hog observations and/or observed evidence of wild hog damage.”

In Flagler County, marauding wild pigs became so widespread earlier this year that officials created a feral hog dashboard for sightings, according to the Daytona Beach News-Journal.

“This quality of life has been severely dampened by the chronic anxiety, fear, anger and exasperation felt by our residents,” Nancy Crouch, a resident of the Grand Haven development in Flagler County, said during a county workshop. “… I don’t want to be in the news for, you know, not doing anything about feral hogs that are attacking humans.”

Drones, helicopters and automatic rifles spell danger for pigs

Still, when it’s a matter of life or death, humans pose a far greater threat to pigs than hogs could ever pose to humans.

In Texas, people can sign up to shoot the pigs with automatic rifles from moving helicopters. In Mississippi, legislators have proposed a bill this year that would allow the use of drones to hunt hogs. In Florida, the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission requires no license to hunt them. There is no off-season, and most places do not have bag or size limits. Killing hogs has long been a rite of passage for young hunters in the area, as they are plentiful and make for easy, accessible prey.

In recent years, the Internet brought even more popularity to the sport: Videos of people spraying hogs with bullets from helicopters or taking them out with military-grade snipers have garnered millions of views on YouTube. Last week, a popular streamer named “Tfue” was lambasted online for livestreaming himself hunting pigs in Florida. In the video, a pig, squealing in pain, can be seen running away after he shoots it multiple times.

“I feel bad,” Tfue says, then laughs. “You want to spear him dude? I don’t want him to suffer.”

Later, to defend himself, the streamer posted on X a list of problems the hogs pose to Florida.

A hunter himself, Wright Jr. worries that killings pigs indiscriminately, along with the rise of predators like the Burmese python, could upset the natural balance in places like South Florida’s Everglades where they are a vital part of the food chain. He wishes wildlife officials could find a way to redistribute the hogs to areas where they have been overhunted.

“When I was a kid, hogs were everywhere down South Florida way,” said Wright Jr. “The panthers and the snakes have pretty much decimated the hog population. Not that the panthers or the snakes have a bag limit or a size limit.”

He added, “there’s hardly any hogs due to all three predators, man being one of them.”

Even though hunting is popular, Mayer says trapping and euthanizing is the most effective approach when it comes to actually reducing the number of pigs.

“Hunting doesn’t take enough of these animals in any given year to keep populations low,” he said. “These things just crank out too many little feet every year for hunting to be effective.”

The extent to which hunting has reduced wild pig populations in Florida is unclear. An FWC spokesperson did not respond to questions about their numbers and if they have gotten too low in certain areas.

The damage to the economy both in Florida and nationwide is real. Farmers have enlisted Greene to remove pigs from orange groves, where they knock over trees or eat the saplings. Nationally, wild hogs are estimated to cause $1.5 billion in economic damages per year, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. And while some areas may benefit from a hog or two, research has shown that they have overwhelmingly destroyed Florida ecosystems and habitats while competing with native species.

Meanwhile, a disease the wild pigs spread called African Swine Fever has wrought havoc in Asia over the last few years and could devastate the U.S. pork industry if it ever crossed the ocean.

“It’s the ultimate kiss of death for pigs,” said Mayer. “If it ever got into this country the way it spread through Eurasia, it would be the death knell of U.S. pork industry. You wouldn’t be able to buy bacon anymore.”

Scientists are working on less violent solutions, like oral contraceptives, but “they haven’t really cracked that nut yet,” Mayer said, because they don’t know how that might affect the predators who eat the pigs.

Wild hog cuisine has also become more desirable, at least for some people. Greene has clients in Miami who buy his pigs to cook around Christmas or Thanksgiving, sometimes 50 at a time.

“There are a lot more wild boar dishes in restaurants now,” said Mayer. “But we’re not gonna barbecue our way out of this.”

A true pig-proof fence may not exist, but a reinforced fence has brought peace to Prendergast’s Miramar neighborhood, at least for now. Word is that the hogs, who he thinks are a mother, father and child, have wandered off to terrorize nearby communities.

Prendergast is an animal lover who spends his spare time watching the birds on the lake across from his house. He wishes there were 2 acres of wild land for every 1 acre of developed land. He doesn’t have too much ill will toward the pigs. But he’s glad they’re gone.

“Those guys, they can do damage, I’ll tell you that,” Prendergast said. “They can do damage.”

Friday, January 13, 2023

Sarasotan designs new logo for the Right to Clean Water

 

“A ‘Right to Clean and Healthy Waters'" is a green amendment crafted specifically to meet the legal and political challenges in Florida” - Joseph Bonasia, Communications Director for FloridaRightToCleanWater.org


A call to support the right to clean water in Florida

In 2020, the Orange County Charter Review Commission placed a charter amendment on the ballot. It was designed to guarantee that Orange County waters had a right to be clean and free of pollution. The amendment also granted all county citizens the right to clean water. It passed with 89.2% voter approval.

Shortly after placement on the ballot, however, the state legislature preempted the authority of local governments to pass such laws. Because of this, a lawsuit using the new amendment to protect wetlands in the county from development was challenged by both the developer and the state. The lawsuit was dismissed, but the appeal is being prepared.

Work began immediately on a state constitutional amendment because the constitution can’t be circumvented.

The 2024 ballot is a feasible goal. Many new venues, such as virtual meetings, now were available for our organizational meetings and presentations to members of organizations supporting the effort. Consensus developed quickly to focus on one amendment and leadership changes occurred. The Florida Right To Clean Water (RtCW) campaign for a state constitutional amendment began coming together both in its legal form and development of the statewide network that would function in each county or region.

Working closely with the new leaders, I mentioned my proposal for a redesign of the logo that would be important for attracting voters who were not committed participants in “things environmental.” 

Joseph Bonasia, Southwest Florida RtCW leader, described it as “a new and improved logo, for a new and improved amendment”:


Now we in Sarasota need to provide our fair share of the required signatures on petitions. That is where you come in. We need your signatures on the petitions and we need your help getting others (at
 least five friends).

At Floridarighttocleanwater.org you can get the petition — then mail it to the Fort Myers address.* Find answers to questions about the campaign, and see the growing support: League of Women Voters, VoteWater.org, Florida Wildlife Federation, and Waterkeeper chapters among them. If you can, join the volunteer effort in any way convenient for you — become an ambassador or a captain. Even if you are not a Florida voter, with a little volunteered work or a donation you can participate in this clean water effort.

It is up to us to get this question before the voters — so they may decide whether to guarantee that we have the clean water we have been pursuing fruitlessly for decades — instead of things just getting worse.



*Mail to: 
FloridaRightToCleanWater.org
(Political Committee)
13300 S Cleveland Ave, Ste 56
Fort Myers, FL 33907

Tuesday, January 4, 2022

Suncoast Waterkeeper: A look back and what's ahead

 A newsletter from the group that sued Sarasota County leading to major wastewater plant upgrades:

Suncoast Waterkeeper

We want to wish a happy new year to the entire Suncoast Waterkeeper family.  Our waterways and natural areas support the local economy and quality of life.  Together, we fought to protect our water in 2021 and, with your help, will continue to work to preserve what makes the Suncoast special.  

Here’s a look back at our work in 2021 and a preview of what we’re working on for 2022:

Piney Point

Piney Point has been a ticking time bomb.  Due to neglect and inaction, the State of Florida was forced to dump over 200 million gallons of contaminated water into Tampa Bay.  Over the course of 2021, we experienced some of the worst red tides, other harmful algae blooms and fish kills that we have ever seen.  The threat doesn’t end there.  Now the State of Florida and DEP are working to inject the wastewater into our aquifer without adequate testing or filtration.  

That is why we launched and are continuing to pursue a federal lawsuit to safely close Piney Point with other partners and organizations in the region.  

In addition to the lawsuit, we hosted educational forums and conducted advocacy campaigns to demand better from our local and state elected officials on Piney Point.  

Stopping Sewage Spills   

Our region has suffered from numerous sewage spills due to poor management of aging environmental infrastructure.  According to the City of Bradenton’s own reports, 160 million gallons of raw and partially treated sewage was dumped into the Manatee River over the last four years.  This contributed to declining conditions in our estuaries.  In 2021, we filed a notice of intent to sue the City of Bradenton over repeated sewage spills into our waterways.  We hope to resolve our case against Bradenton in 2022. Our previous sewage lawsuits have resulted in major investments in wastewater infrastructure and fewer sewage spills.  Together, we’re going to continue our work to reduce sewage spills on the Suncoast. 

Water Quality Monitoring 

To enjoy our waterways, we need to ensure that they are clean.  We sample water quality weekly to keep our community informed about the water they rely on for recreation, work and more.  In 2022, because of your support, we’ll continue to monitor water quality in our waterways.  

Monitoring Public Information & Demanding Accountability

In many ways, regulation and oversight in Florida is broken.  Our regulators have repeatedly ignored or failed to address threats to our water quality, quality of life and local economy.  That’s why we regularly monitor public records for information on water quality, pollution, harmful algae blooms and new and existing projects.  Monitoring this information allows us to let you know what is happening in our community and lets us know when we need to take action.  

Your support means that we’ll be able to continue to work to protect our water.  We can’t afford to let pollution, contamination and inaction from our government officials threaten our water, quality of life and local economy.  Together, we’ll continue to make a difference in 2022. 

Thank you, 

Suncoast Waterkeeper
http://www.suncoastwaterkeeper.org/

Monday, April 12, 2021

What are the duties of county commissioners anyway . . .

 From: Herald Tribune, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, April 10, 2021


Board of Sarasota County Commissioners


Pondering duties, obligations of government

I am fairly new to the area, and very confused about the role of government in Florida.

Here in Sarasota County, commissioners had no problem approving the monstrous mall development at the intersection of U.S. 41 and Stickney Point Road.

Question: Do the county commissioners approve every development, no matter how much a proposal is opposed by residents?

A few days ago, as I approached that intersection, traffic was backed up at least a mile in every direction. Once the massive hotel and retail outlets are squeezed into the Siesta Promenade, I would hate to have to evacuate the key in an emergency.

What are the duties of county commissioners anyway, and whom do they serve?

A Florida Senate committee in January found time to pass a resolution denouncing democratic socialism, although the members failed to define what it is – Social Security, Medicare or something more dangerous?

But over the past decades Florida lawmakers have not found time to prevent the clearly predictable ecological disaster at Piney Point. What is a greater threat – some nonexistent legislation the senators might call socialism, or the millions and millions of gallons of wastewater being dumped into Tampa Bay?

Just curious.

James Medlin, Sarasota


Sunday, March 7, 2021

The Future of Sarasota - Evolution or Devolution?

Sarasota is 100 years old this year. The Library is holding several public events in honor of the Centennial, including this one about the next 100 years. 

David Houle
The Future of Sarasota
Futurist David Houle will give a presentation on the future of Sarasota County over the next 100 years. He won a Speaker of the Year award from Vistage International, the leading organization of CEOs in the world. This virtual program will be hosted in Zoom.
Register Now









B


This should be a lively program - far livelier than the dreary meetings our elected officials and various boards - like the Planning Commission - manage to come up with whenever they face the public's failure to understand why its concerns never seem to be dignified with honest, detailed discussions. 

Why is Sarasota facing a preemption of its residents' right to think comprehensively, with vision, about the future? Can we be sustainable, innovative, environmentally sound, and pace ourselves? Can we begin to acknowledge the Rights of Nature? Can we remember that Sarasota let the state in envisioning the future? 

Why are we allowing people we elect to give away vast amounts of open land to gated community developers who have nothing new to offer, nothing that bodes well for schools, community, or the environment. Just more of same, a path leading to a kind of unsustainable lifestyle for anything except those who wish to escape community altogether?




There's a brien narrative of how the state built a fairly sensible model of comprehensive planning, then blew it to smithereens that every Floridian should read. It traces the arc of responsible state comprehensive planning in Florida - its birth, evolution, and eventual destruction at the hands of Rick Scott in 2011.

Does the public have any right to meaningful development in Sarasota? Meaningful, that is, culturally, environmentally, socially, aesthetically and economically?

 It's not a story to be proud of, but it's certainly one to be fully and consistently aware of: Florida's Growth Management Odyssey: Revolution, Evolution, Devolution, Resolution - Robert M. Rhodes, 2020


Thursday, February 25, 2021

In Florida, a river gains right to Flow



In the summer of 2020, the Little Wekiva River appeared to die. In the span of less than two years, the creek north of downtown Orlando, Florida, had dwindled from the width of a two-lane road to a muddy trickle. Then, in the midst of one of the rainiest hurricane seasons on record, it ran dry. Locals walked the riverbed in befuddled dismay. It was as though the river had simply vanished.

Then came the November 2020 election—and local citizens’ response to the chronic water pollution. Residents of Orange County, the home of Orlando’s theme parks as well as its biologically rich wetlands, voted to amend their county charter to grant rights to the Econlockhatchee and Wekiva Rivers. The Right to Clean Water Charter Amendment declares that “all Citizens of Orange County have a right to clean water” and that the county’s waterways have a “right to exist, Flow, to be protected against Pollution, and to maintain a healthy ecosystem.”

The election outcome made Orange County the most populous jurisdiction in the United States to recognize legal rights for nature. More than 500,000 people voted yes on the Right to Clean Water Charter Amendment, making this seemingly esoteric legislation, which passed by a landslide margin of 89 to 11 percent, the most popular item on the ballot. 

“The Orange County law recognizes a human right to clean water,” says Thomas Linzey, senior legal counsel for the Center for Democratic and Environmental Rights, who has spent much of the past 20 years crafting similar rights-of-nature legislation around the globe. 


Saturday, August 15, 2020

Corona Virus in Florida: The numbers

From Mike Lasche, 8.14.20:


    Today, August 14, Florida set more records and recorded more high numbers of Coronavirus.

Today’s reported fatalities were 228, the 5th highest daily total of the pandemic.   The record, of 276, was set on Tuesday, August 11.

Today’s reported new hospitalizations were 618, the second highest ever, just 3 shy of the record of 621, set on August 5.    Today was also the 4th day in a row that reported new hospitalizations topped 500.

The 7 Day Average of Hospitalizations is at an all-pandemic high of 489, which means that there have been 3,486 new reported hospitalizations over the last week.

The 14 Day Average of Hospitalizations is at an all-pandemic high of 473, which means that there have been 6,622 new reported hospitalizations over the last two weeks.

The closeness of of the 7 Day and 14 Day Average of Hospitalizations suggests a consistent trend.     

With the 7 Day Average being more than the 14 Day Average, this means that new reported hospitalizations are increasing.

The increasing number of hospitalizations suggest that the virus is having a more serious impact on Florida than in the past…………and that the high number of confirmed cases are indeed leading to serious illness.

More ominously, with there being a steady trend of roughly 1 fatality for every four hospitalizations throughout the pandemic, a rise in hospitalizations augurs a rise in fatalities.

Below, please find tables and data which support the conclusions above.


Mike Lasche
Florida Walks and Bikes


p.s.   Mike is not an epidemiologist but has significant experience in analysis of data in the public, private, academic, and non-profit sectors.    These conclusions and data are offered as a public service, to further the understanding of the coronavirus pandemic in Florida.   Comments, criticisms, and questions are welcome.

==============


Below, please find a table which shows the daily reported fatalities from July 31 to August 14.  Note today’s total of 228 and the record of 276, set on August 11.   Notice how the 7 Day Average of Fatalities is increasing since August 7.





Below, please find a table which shows the daily reported Hospitalizations from July 31 to August 14.   Notice today’s total of 618 and the record of 621, set on August 5.    Also notice the record 7 Day Average, set today.





Below, please find two graphs, the 7 Day Average of Hospitalizations and the 14 Day Average of Hospitalizations, through the pandemic.   Note that both are at all-pandemic highs.   Note that the 7 Day Average ends on a higher number than the 14 Day Average, which means that the number of fatalities is increasing, week to week.





Finally, here is a graph which shows fatalities, as a percentage of all hospitalizations, remaining at a relatively steady rate for several months.   The rate has remained around 25% since early May.   Please note that this is not intended to be a measure of the effectiveness of hospitalization, as a good percentage of fatalities, perhaps 15-30% occur without prior hospitalizations.   But, it can serve as a rough guide to the number of fatalities to be expected, based on the number of people hospitalized.



Saturday, June 6, 2020

Be Prepared: Lucas on protecting your vote



Adrien Lucas:


1) Get registered to vote ASAP if you're eligible.

2) Confirm your voter registration once EVERY month to make sure:
a. that you haven't been purged from the voter roll.
b. that your voter information is accurate and updated.
c. that you know where your polling place is located.

3) If your state or county offers Early Voting, find the days/times/locations and make a personalized Election Day plan based on your life and schedule.

4) If your state or county offers Absentee/Vote By Mail ballots, sign up to receive them and make Election Day arrive conveniently in your mailbox.

5) If your state has political party affiliation restrictions on who can vote in presidential preference and primary elections, make sure you know those dates and notify your local elections office about your political party affiliation before the deadlines.

6) Florida operates with a 'closed primary' voting and elections system - that means the state only allows party affiliated voters to cast ballots for all of the partisan races in the presidential preference and primary nomination elections.

If you want to vote in the 2020 Florida presidential preference and primary
nomination elections, you MUST be eligible to vote AND register your political party affiliation with your county Supervisor Of Elections office no later than 29 days before that election. There is no cost or obligation associated with registering your political party affiliation with your SOE office.

You may change your political party affiliation with your SOE office at any time. Registering or changing your political party affiliation with your SOE office does NOT mean that you have 'joined a political party' - one joins a political party as a separate process, typically with a payment and a pledge to the local/county/state political party chapter.

You have no fiscal responsibility or individual obligation to fulfill to any political party by making a party preference affiliation with your SOE office, it is simply an administrative record telling a non-partisan government agency which party ballot you wish to participate in for the presidential preference and primary nomination elections.

Florida Primary Nomination Election is August 18, 2020 - you must register/note/switch your political party affiliation by July 20, 2020.
Florida General Election is November 3, 2020 - you must register by October 5, 2020.

And if you have ANY questions about any voting or election law or policy ASK ME ANYTHING/ANYTIME you want, day/night 24/7. I know a lot, and what I don't know I'll be able to find out quickly and easily.

—————

www.sarasotavotes.com
www.votemanatee.com
https://registertovoteflorida.gov/en/Registration/Index
https://www.usa.gov/register-to-vote

Thursday, May 28, 2020

The History of Single Member Districts in Sarasota County, Florida

 Contributed by Kindra Muntz of Sarasota Alliance for Fair Elections (SAFE)

The first referendum to change County Commission elections from At-large to single member districts passed in 1992, but was overturned in 1994 after a concerted campaign by moneyed interests supporting the majority of Commissioners.  The reasons for changing to single member districts in 1992 were the same then as they were for the campaign that started in 2016: to restore integrity to county elections by returning them to the grassroots; empower neighborhoods, reduce control of big money over elections, and reduce the cost of campaigning by 80%.  In 1992 the population of Sarasota County was 284,880.  By 2016 it had grown by 50% to 412, 968.  Sarasota County is now the 14th largest of 67 counties statewide.  It is so big that it encompasses three and a half statewide legislative districts, each of which elects its State Representative in the district.  Also, of the 13 larger counties and two immediately smaller, nine use single member districts or a blended system for electing their County Commissioners.

In Sarasota County in 2016, with At-large Commission elections, the cost of campaigning countywide had become prohibitive, so only people with significant funding—often from large developers and dark money PACs—could effectively compete.  The result was that the resulting Commissioners were largely beholden to developers and granted special exceptions and tax breaks that benefited them, and not the people living in the districts. In addition, overruns by developers often meant that we the public taxpayers got to foot the bill.  Having just the voters in each district elect their County Commissioners was seen as a critical way to address this problem.


THE CAMPAIGN

2016

In the spring of 2016, concerned citizens asked SAFE to sponsor a petition drive for two referendums to amend the County Charter to change the way we elect County Commissioners and Charter Review Board members in Sarasota County from At-large to single member district.

In August, SAFE issued a press release “Sarasota Alliance for Fair Elections Sponsors Single-Member District Charter Amendment Petition Drive.”  Interestingly, two days later, a reporter from the Observer newspaper group called to ask how many petitions were required and when we hoped to get the referendum on the ballot. Our SAFE website was updated.  Plans for mobilizing volunteer petition-gatherers were discussed. Volunteers were contacted. In October, signs were purchased “Local Control IN—Big $$$ OUT.”



2017

However, until March, 2017, volunteer efforts were slow.  People seemed distracted by the results of the November, 2016 Presidential election.  SAFE reached out to students from Pine View School to design a T-shirt for volunteers and to help with social media outreach.

Volunteer T-Shirt designed by Pineview students
We researched documents from the citizens’ successful 1992 SMD campaign and the 1994 Commissioner’s ordinance on the ballot that overturned single member districts.  By April we were on the lookout for events for tabling and petition-gathering at libraries, the Nokomis Drum Circle and the April 15th Bridge Walk. Supervisor of Elections Ron Turner confirmed that the number of verified petitions required was 15,096, or 5% of the registered voters in the last General Election (11-8-2016), or 301,925 voters.

By May, only 1,300 petitions of each had been collected. Enhanced petition-gathering strategies included outreach at Farmers’ Markets, walking Main Street Sarasota, Siesta Beach, use of colored paper for petitions, and online encouragement of petition-gathering using Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, website, and email blasts. Coalition partners were needed. By August, our goal of having 17,000 signed petitions by December 31 seemed no longer reachable. We decided not to gather petitions outside until October due to the hot weather.  We discussed using paid petition-gatherers and the need to raise money to pay them, but no decision was made.  We decided to expand the SAFE board with more diversity of viewpoint. Dan Lobeck was invited and accepted our invitation to serve on the board.  Ron Turner said suggested deadlines for petitions for the August 28 Primary in 2018 would be April 18, for the November 6 General Election would be June 28.

October 2, 2017 we voted to limit the petition drive to County Commission elections only. Volunteers said it was too hard to explain the Charter Review Board to people.  October 6, 2017 we launched an all-out effort to raise funds to hire paid petition-gatherers to supplement our volunteer efforts for two months. A local coordinator of paid petition-gatherers was engaged, along with a professional coordinator from October 13-December 15.

Our own volunteers kept gathering petitions at the Sun Fiesta, sports events, the Sarasota County Fair, the Critical Times conference, LWV meetings, Tiger Bay meetings, CONA meetings, and the Nina Turner event at the Venice Yacht Club.

2018

February, 2018 We decided to try to gather enough petitions to hold a Special Election in June, to benefit the County Commission candidates in Districts 2 and 4 on the November ballot. Ron Turner said all petitions must be in by March 16 to do that.  Even with help of paid petition-gatherers from another group, we couldn’t achieve that goal. Our volunteers kept gathering petitions. We engaged MDW Communications to build the website for Single Member Districts. We had to decide whether we would aim to be on the ballot in the November, 2018 election or wait for a Special Election in March, 2019.

June 22, 2018 SAFE turned in the last batch of petitions needed to qualify our referendum. We held a press conference outside the front door of the Terrace building to announce that we go for the November, 2018 General Election ballot.  However, in July, Kafi Benz of CONA warned that the BCC was also considering changing the petition requirements from 5% to 10% (15,000 to 30,000 petitions) for any future efforts and shortening the time to gather them.

August, 2018 the new website singlememberdistricts.com was launched.



August 16 was the Tiger Bay panel with Dan Lobeck and Hugh Culverhouse vs. Nora Patterson and John Wesley White. August 29 was the public hearing of the BCC to adopt the ordinance to place our amendment on the ballot. Our fundraising efforts continued to support a ground game to reach voters and digital advertising and postcard mailers to supplement the presentations Dan and Kindra were giving at various events, and the guest columns they were submitting to various newspapers.

Sept. 14 Kindra did a livestream at Beef O’Brady’s in North Port with Ruta Jouniari. September and October, 2018 more forums with Kindra and Dan at Holley Hall, and Selby Library.

November 6  The Midterm General Election!  The Single Member Districts referendum passed with 59.84% YES, vs. 40.16% NO.  A major victory!  Unfortunately, the deceptively worded referendum by the County Commissioners also passed, that changed petition requirements to amend the County Charter in the future from 5% to 10% (15,000 to 30,000 petitions) and shortened the time for gathering petitions.  It was obvious the County Commission wanted to silence the voices of the voters.

THE OPPOSITION

In March of 2018, Christine Robinson of the Argus Foundation learned the progress of SAFE’s petition-gathering efforts at the Supervisor of Elections office and raised an alarm.  Christian Ziegler sent an urgent e-blast to alert everyone and raise money for his campaign for County Commission District 2.
By May, guest columns from local developers and Republican Party Acting Chair Jack Brill were printed assailing the single member district effort.
At the August 16 Tiger Bay panel, Nora Patterson and John Wesley White opposed single member districts while Dan Lobeck and Hugh Culverhouse supported them.

September 18, 2018 the political committee Stop! Stealing Our Votes was formed. $85,000 was raised initially from builder’s groups, the Sarasota Chamber of Commerce, and led by the Argus Foundation that donated $50,000. Stop! Stealing Our Votes signs were planted all over the county. Glossy mailers started being sent to voters countywide to oppose single member districts, from Political Ink, Inc. in Washington, DC.  Digital media, online advertising, and a website were developed by Strategic Digital Services in Tallahassee. The developer-funded opposition mounted an aggressive and deceptive campaign both in mailers and social media, stealing SAFE’s message by actually claiming that single member districts will increase the power of the big money developers.

Funds kept being raised in October for more digital ads and more mailers opposing Single member districts.

Altogether the opposition raised over $155,000.00 to defeat our Single Member District referendum. But they LOST at the November 6 election!

So in January, 2019 the County Commissioners started planning to redistrict the County in 2019 before the decennial census, to gerrymander County districts so they could keep control over this county, with the help of their developer and business friends and…the Argus Foundation.

                                                                       -- Kindra Muntz, May 28, 2020





Friday, September 6, 2019

UPDATE: 9.11: Commission to unveil new district voting maps - SEE MAPS BELOW

Surprise! Surprise!

With slow and no response to public records requests and with minimal public notice, Sarasota County will unveil its proposed new District-level maps next week. All this stems from the Board's decision in April to explore reconsideration of the boundaries of the five county districts, in light of the new Single Member Voting.

Please attend the County Commission meeting Wednesday morning 9 AM:

County Administration Building
County Commission Chambers, 1st Floor
1660 Ringling Blvd, Sarasota

Why this matters: Cathy Antunes

Show your opposition to this “plan”. An Open to the Public session will 
precede the Redistricting discussion. See you on Wednesday!

 <<<<BREAKING NEWS: Here are the maps Spitzer will present Wednesday:>>>>






Kurt Spitzer
Kurt Spitzer, redistricting consultant hired by Sarasota County with a no-bid
contract, will review the “alternative” District maps created with private 
input from individual County Commissioners.
How’s that FL Sunshine Law workin’ for ya? 


Board of County Commissioners Agenda: Page 1
1. OPEN TO THE PUBLIC – (Three-minute time limit per person.)

How open is it?  From The Sarasota News Leader:
Additionally, county Media Relations Officer Drew Winchester
confirmed with staff that, as of late afternoon on Sept. 4, three of the
commissioners — Charles Hines, Nancy Detert and Christian Ziegler —
have scheduled one-on-one telephone conversations with the consultant
who is handling the redistricting initiative for the county,
Kurt Spitzer of Tallahassee. The Sarasota News Leader
Will this telephone conversations be recorded? Will it be known how long
they lasted, what was discussed?
While the consultant and commissioners huddle over the phone preparing their own maps, the information needed by and promised to the public is being withheld.

Is it ignorance or incompetence?

It isn't ignorance. The commissioners were told during the final open to the public comments on August 27 that the deliverables from Spitzer and Associates (block-level GIS data) were not publicly available.

It might be incompetence. 

County staff says, "The [block level] data was in an Aug. 2 memorandum from Spitzer to the County Commission." 

The memo, however, does not contain the county-wide block needed by the public to produce their own redistricting maps. Instead, it provides info for "key growth blocks by district."  

Despite repeated public records requests from several citizens, as of September 5, the County and Spitzer had provided block-level population data for only:
  1. 6% of the population (23,153 out of an estimated 417,000 Sarasota County residents)
  2. 1% of the blocks (92 out of about about 7,500 Sarasota County census blocks) 
Finally on Sept. 6, a public records request for block data from The Sarasota News Leader was responded to. According to the county,  the entire block data spreadsheet is now here.

By the deadline [contract deadline July 31] , just one of the deliverables below -- Part (c) -- was delivered -- two days late, on August 2.

Part (b) was provided to the public late on September 6

Spitzer & Associates has not fulfilled their Task 1 contractual obligations, and the county has been laggard in providing the data necessary for the public to prepare alternate maps. (see below)

If it's not incompetence, they know exactly what they're doing -- withholding information to prevent an informed public response to the maps being presented on September 11.


Image of districts formerly used on BCC web page


===

By the deadline, just one of the deliverables below -- (c) -- was provided:
Copies of Task 1 Deliverables from SC PO #193092.. Vendor: KURT SPITZER AND ASSOCIATES INC...Including:  
(a.) GIS - The 2010 and 2018 population estimates in file geodatabase or shapefile format at the 2010 Census Block level of geography. 
(b.) Spreadsheet - Block-level results will be summarized by commission district and exported to Excel format. 
(c.) Report – A narrative report describing the methodology used to update the 2010 Census data. THIS WAS PROVIDED 
(d.) Map - A “heat map” in PDF format showing 2010-2018 growth by block. It will be shaded semi-transparent with imagery as a base. Commission district boundaries will be shown. A table summarizing the population estimates by BCC District will be included on the map showing the following 2018 information:  
 BCC District number Average (mean) population  Actual population Deviation from the mean Percent deviation White population and Percent white population Black population and Percent black population Hispanic population and Percent Hispanic population Other population and Percent other population.

Thursday, November 8, 2018

Broken Banana


Republicans broke Florida politics. Things won’t be better there next time.

Democrats always think they’re one election away from taking back the state.

November 7, 2018 at 5:20 PM
Sen.-elect Rick Scott, governor of Florida, addresses an election-night rally Tuesday in Naples, Fla. (Jayme Gershen/Bloomberg)
I am not writing this from Florida proper, but from an occupied territory within Florida’s borders. I hail from Broward County, where roughly 7 in 10 voters this year chose Democrats over Republicans, and where none — not a single one — of those Democrats won their five statewide races outright Tuesday.
Andrew Gillum, the Tallahassee mayor who would have been Florida’s first black governor, led 16 of 17 polls taken in the state since mid-October and was given a 77 percent chance of winning by FiveThirtyEight’s projection model. He appears to have lost to Republican Rep. Ron DeSantis, who was credibly accused of running a racistfearmongering campaign, by about 50,000 votes out of more than 8 million cast. Bill Nelson, the incumbent Democratic senator, was widely expected to win, pulled along on the dynamic Gillum’s coattails. Nelson is currently losing statewide to tycoon and outgoing GOP Gov. Rick Scott by fewer about 30,000 votes out of 8.1 million.
My corner of Florida, the state’s bluest and one of its most populous, voted for Democrats in concentrations that rival those of Philadelphia, Manhattan and Chicago. And many state Democrats are pointing to some positive signs: They flipped two House seats in South Florida. They got voters to restore the franchise to the state’s estimated 1.7 million convicted felons, while banning offshore drilling and indoor vaping. Key West elected its first openly lesbian mayor, which is awesome, and would be even more awesome if I could afford to live in Key West or had any assurance that it won’t be strangled by sea-level rise before I die. In any case, some Democrats look at last night’s results and say, hey, Florida is still within reach.
Sure. It’s been just within reach since 2006, the last time a Democrat won a statewide office.
As pundits go crazy trying to reconcile the Sunshine State’s turnout with the national results, let me offer my own theory: “Florida” is increasingly a meaningless political entity, except in Republican electoral win columns. It is not a purple state, but a dystopian Republican frontier of America’s systematic “Big Sort” — a collection of ultra-blue principalities surrounded by and alienated from an entrenched ultrared state government.
Do you seek a bellwether for the United States’ chances of surviving Trumpism? Look to Florida, where the Mar-a-Lago spirit has been a governing ethos for many years already. So you want to know how Florida survives. The answer is it probably won’t — not as a functioning state that tends to the needs of its 21 million people. Florida is going to get more divided, less governable, and probably more susceptible to oligarchs and fiefdoms than it already is.
That’s the way Republicans have made it since they gained a trifecta in the state in the 1990s. A quarter-century of GOP legislative dominance has wrecked state services, created a haven for tax-hating rural retirees, gerrymandered districts repeatedly and relentlessly, bloated Tallahassee with outside money and lobbying influence, and created an electoral infrastructure that reliably delivers 50.1 percent of the vote to, uh, whatever Republican you’ve got. The party then accumulates those slight victories into a decades-long mandate, ensconcing its elite, rendering any alternative governance increasingly hard and unlikely.
Rick Scott is the Meriwether Lewis of this Republican strategy, the party’s prototypical pioneering wealthy neophyte candidate. After eight years in the governor’s mansion, his first public-sector job, Scott — like Trump — remains largely incompetentawkwardignorant of normsfull of fake optimism and loved only by his strongest partisans. But unlike Trump, Scott is capable of shutting up, comfortable telling more conventional lies and actually willing to blow massive portions of his dubiously gotten personal fortune to stay in races he should lose.
As of Wednesday afternoon — as his edge over Nelson hovers around recount territory — Scott has won three statewide elections in eight years by a total margin of 155,871 votes out of 18,976,891 cast, or 0.8 percent of the total vote. In those three elections, Scott pumped at least $124 million of his own wealth into his campaigns. If you believe public records, Scott has spent more than half of his net worth (or less than a quarter of his family’s net worth) to squeak out three victory margins just above automatic recount level. In Tuesday’s race, as in previous ones, he bought a slew of last-minute ads appealing to the id-impulses of Floridians. Scott won over-65s by double digits in this retiree-heavy state, although by Election Day his campaign message had largely boiled down to “Look how old my opponent is!
DeSantis, Scott’s gubernatorial heir apparent, called his black opponent “Andrew Kill-em,” parroted Trump lies calling Gillum’s hometown of Tallahassee the state’s murder and crime capital, refused to return campaign donations from an outspoken racist supporter, and told voters not to “monkey this up” by voting for Gillum’s “socialist,” “extreme radical” ideas.
“I’m not calling Mr. DeSantis a racist,” Gillum responded. “I’m simply saying the racists believe he’s a racist.” DeSantis won 6 of 10 white voters in Florida on Tuesday.How did he and Scott run up enough of a margin in conservative counties to counterbalance the historic blue turnout in places such as South Florida? We may never really know, I suppose. In unrelated news, 65 percent of Walton County voters approved a measure Tuesday to fly a rebel flag on a local courthouse that bills itself as “Florida’s first Confederate monument.” They also voted for DeSantis over Gillum by 52.5 percentage points.
So, yes, you can look at the consistent Republican overperformance against polls in Florida in 2010, 2012, 2014, 2016 and now 2018, and say that, without the obscene amounts of money and animus, plus a quarter-century of single-party domination, all these squeaker contests might otherwise be walkovers for sanity. But this is what Florida is. This is what it’s been molded into. The state is not going to get bluer: But its blue oases will, even as a red tide permanently claims more and more of the lands between them.
Take the ostensible victory of the night: voters’ approval of Amendment 4, which extends the franchise to the roughly 10 percent of the state population who have been convicted of a felony. Florida felons are now theoretically able to vote, but they’re practically reliant on a Republican governor, secretary of state and legislature not standing in the way of their attempts to exercise those restored rights. Democratic hopes (and GOP fears) of a blue wave in 2020 led by the newly franchised in Florida seem Pollyanna-ish when you look at the state’s gerrymandering and voter-suppression tactics in recent decades — though those look tame when compared with anti-voter GOP regimes in states such as Georgia and North Carolina.
Even if Florida Democrats start winning, they’ll have to contend with another newly approved amendment to the state Constitution that makes raising taxes impossible without a supermajority of votes in the legislature. In other words, if any politician in this 50.5 percent majority state actually wanted to improve a crumbling state Department of Children and Families, or beef up public disaster and health-crisis response, or rebuild a gutted public education budget, they’d have to get two-thirds of the state House and Senate to agree. (Republicans maintain comfortable, largely impregnable majorities in both chambers.)
For all the talk about Florida’s purpleness and unpredictability, for all of the Democratic turnout efforts and number-crunching and target-hitting, we have a stable model: The blue parts get bluer, while the red parts get redder, the election results stay slightly red, and the entrenched political culture gets much redder. In the future, Democrats will find more voters here, and Republicans will find more ways to make it hard for those votes to be counted, and even harder for them to lead to changes in government. There is no center to hold, only anarchy loosed upon the third-largest state in America.